Press Any Button was started by Nicky Smith and Eric Luedtke at the tail end of 2020 with the goal of covering a wide variety of games. The hosts take turns picking games, writing the history, and coming up with challenges for each episode. On episodes with guests, the guest is usually allowed to decide on the game and challenge. Episode are recorded from Nicky and Eric’s home in Kennesaw, Georgia. The episodes are edited by Eric, while Nicky creates the art and manages the social media accounts.